Ithaca Agway

Header-sm Brand Products Sold Here


Save as my store Find other stores

ITHACA, NY, 14850
Directions from Google Maps

Phone: 607-272-1848
Fax: 607-272-1706
Hours: MON-FRI: 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM; SAT: 8:00 AM - 5:00 PM; SUN: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM


Ithaca Agway & True Value started in 1920 as the premier store for the GLF (Grange League Federation), a farmers’ cooperative existing for the good of its customers. It provided the goods that family farmers needed at an affordable price.

While the world has changed a lot since then, Ithaca Agway has not forgotten its roots. We strive to have the products you need to get your home and work projects done, along with providing the knowledge you need about how to get the job done.

A customer described us best when he said our service was the closest to an old-time general store that he has ever seen. This general store serves the basic needs of farmers, homeowners, landscapers, and contractors, as well as modern-day customers looking for natural / holistic pet food, organic plant foods or pest control, and  the newest varieties of perennials and annuals. Visit us for your pet, wild bird, home, or farm needs. You’ll be impressed at the assortment we stock for our customers.

Store Services

  • Small Engine Service & Parts - We service what we sell. If something goes wrong with any piece of outdoor power equipment sold at Ithaca Agway, we don’t send it off to some other repair center. Our factory trained mechanics will repair or service your equipment in our in-store small engine service center, a factory authorized service center.
  • Custom House and Wall Paint Color Matching -At Ithaca Agway, you can choose from a wide array of paint colors, or you can bring us a paint chip or wallpaper swatch and we'll match it in minutes.
  • Window Screen Repair -Bring in your window or door screen and let us replace the screen with aluminum, fiberglass or heavy pet resistant screening. Available March 1st to December 1st.
  • Pipe Cutting and Threading -Instead of installing a collection of off the shelf pipe lengths and couplings, let us cut and thread a piece of galvanized or black pipe to the length you need to produce a professional looking job.
  • Sharpening Service - If you are tired of mangling instead of cutting, bring in your knives and scissors to be professionally sharpened. We also sharpen mower blades, reel mowers, saw blades, planer blades and chainsaw chains. Unfortunately, we do not sharpen hand saws or animal clipper blades
  • Glass and Plexiglass Cutting -Single glass and Plexiglass can be cut to size for pictures frames or any other project you may have in mind.
  • Hydraulic Hose Replacement - We use Gates Co. fittings and hose to custom make a replacement hose to match your broken hydraulic hose.
  • Key Duplication - We can duplicate most single, double or plastic head keys.
  • Propane Tank Filling -Portable propane tanks with OPD valves up 100lb are filled on site so you get to keep your tank and not an exchanged tank. We also fill tanks for propane forklifts and RVs.

 Our Staff

  • Andy Boerman: Owner & General Manager
    For information on pavers and wall stones.
  • Dan Lee: Store & Garden Department Manager
    For information on donations, employment, and fundraising.
  • Pet, Wild Bird and Housewares Department
    For information on pets, wild birds, grills, canning supplies, footwear, and outdoor apparel.
  • Hardware Department
    For information on hardware, paints, fencing, plumbing, electrical, pole barns, and buildings.
  • Nursery, Garden, and Gift Department
    For information on garden supplies, lawns, and pest control, nursery stock, seeds, fountains, pottery, and gift items.
  • Livestock and Equine Department
    For information on livestock feeds and supplies.
  • Power Equipment Manager
    For information on lawn equipment, generators, and wood-cutting / splitting equipment.